The combination of “sugar-free” and “ice cream” might sound like nothing but a fantasy. But here we are to bring you a list of the best sugar free ice cream!

The American Heart Association reports you should avoid eating over 25 grams of added sugar. That goes for the majority of the general population. Of course, the bar is much lower if you have heart disease or diabetes.

Displaying a “No Added Sugar” tagline on the products has become a trend for brands selling anything from sandwiches to ice creams. In such a case, it becomes hard to figure out whether there’s some weight behind such boasts.

That’s why we’ve prepped this article on the best sugar-free ice cream. Let’s get started!

A quick glimpse of the ice creams we’ll discuss:

• Ketojoy Chocolate Flavor Ice Cream
• Breyers Vanilla Ice Cream
• Enlightened Dairy-Free Vegan Ice Cream
• So Delicious Vegan Mint Chip Ice Cream
• So Delicious Vegan Vanilla Bean Ice Cream

Best Sugar Free Ice Cream

1. Ketojoy Chocolate Flavor Ice Cream

This is among the most delicious chocolate ice cream options on the market. It’s not only about its flavor but the fact that you can eat it without any guilt. 

Why? Because the carb content is so low.

The sweet dessert is 100% sugar-free, and it doesn’t have any artificial preservatives. Every ingredient is organic and natural. So, if you are on a keto diet, you don’t have to worry about your sugar levels and carbs intake. 

If you happen to be lactose intolerant, you don’t have to worry about eating this ice cream. Not only is it sugar-free, but it’s dairy-free as well. 

When you take a bite of this tasty dessert, it’ll remind you of a combination of chocolate milk and chocolate pudding.

Ketojoy Chocolate Flavor Ice Cream will cost you about $7 to $8.99.

Ingredients:

• Non-GMO
• Himalayan Pink Salt
• Erythritol
• Powder extract from Pure Stevia
• Xylitol
• Fiber from Konjac Root
• Medium-chain Triglycerides
• Vanilla Flavor
• Xanthan Gum

What we liked:

• Keto friendly
• Dairy-free ice cream
• Sugar-free, no-added-sugar
• No added preservatives, no sugar substitutes, 100% organic natural sweeteners

What we disliked:

• Nothing we came across

2. Breyers Vanilla Ice Cream

It’s a creamy and rich frozen dairy dessert that’s made with vanilla flavors and other natural items.

If you’re health-conscious, you don’t have to fret, as this ice cream has no added sugar. Anyone with a sweet tooth can enjoy Breyers. While this option does have sugars found naturally in some of the ingredients, Breyers does not add additional sweeteners.

The product is made with fresh milk, cream, and natural sugar. Breyers uses 100% Grade A cream and milk in their frozen desserts and dairy ice creams. 

You’ll find it interesting that the brand has a partnership with American farmers.

You can expect top-notch, high-quality treats from Breyers. All of their ingredients are inspected carefully and naturally sourced. 

If you’re on a diet, this is a great option. It only has 100 calories per serving — half of the calorie count of other Breyers options.

Also, Breyers Vanilla Ice Cream is hundred percent gluten-free.

Enjoy this delicious frozen dessert with no guilt. You can taste the vanilla sweetness without the added sugar. That is the magic of Breyers. 

At the same time, make sure to control your portions to avoid a high intake of calories. 

Breyers Vanilla Ice Cream costs only around $4 to $5.99.

Ingredients:

• Skim milk
• Annatto
• Maltitol Syrup
• Sucralose
• Maltodextrin (Corn)
• Acesulfame Potassium
• Coconut Oil
• Natural Flavor
• Whey
• Guar Gum
• Cream
• Carob Bean Gum

What we liked:

• Organic and high-quality ingredients
• All the materials are 100% sourced naturally. That includes coconut oil, skim milk,
• cream, and maltitol syrup, among others
• No added preservatives and no artificial hormones
• Gluten-free

What we disliked:

• Not fully sugar-free, as it contains sugars naturally found in some ingredients
• Higher calorie count than other options

3. Enlightened Dairy Free Vegan Ice Cream

These are sugar-free and low-carb ice cream cones that are as delicious as they are healthy. 

As you must know, ice cream cones can be a hit or miss, but Enlightened Cones are definitely the former. 

A wide range of ice cream cones often turn out to be soggy and tasteless, but Enlightened ice cream cones are crispy and yummy. They will not disappoint you. 

There is no compromise in their taste. These ice cream cones are diet-friendly and keto-friendly and are made of 100 percent natural organic ingredients. 

The best part is that there are no preservatives. The low carbs will help you control your carb intake, making it a great choice for health-conscious individuals. 

There are only 30 calories per ice cream cone. Thus, it’s healthy and is a great alternative to sugar and waffle cones. You will be able to satisfy your taste buds without feeling guilty about it.

You can eat these ice cream cones as a snack, and they are a perfect substitute for high-calorie, high-carb nibbles. Plus, even vegans can enjoy these cones without any worries.

You can find 12 cones inside each box. You can also fill the cone with your favorite fruit and yogurt. 

The cone’s crust is sturdy and strong and will be able to hold any food product without getting soggy. 

Enlightened Dairy Free Vegan Ice Cream costs about $6 to $7.99.

Ingredients:

• High Fiber Wheat Flour
• Monk Fruit Extract
• Salt
• Oat Fiber
• Erythritol
• Natural Flavor
• Soluble Corn Fiber
• Soy Lecithin
• Palm Oil

What we liked:

• Low calories
• No sugar
• Low carbs
• Vegan-friendly
• Diet and keto-friendly
• Crispy and sturdy cones

What we disliked:

• There’s only one flavor for sugar-free cones.

4. So Delicious Vegan Mint Chip Ice Cream

Being allergic to gluten and dairy can restrict many people from enjoying sweet treats such as ice cream. But with this treat, you no longer have to worry about dietary restrictions. So Delicious Vegan Mint Chip Ice Cream will satisfy and satiate all your cravings.

It’s a dairy-free and gluten-free ice cream that tastes so delicious that it’ll make you ask for more after finishing one pint. One tub is never enough. Arguably, mint chip is among the best flavors.

With So Delicious’s ice cream, you will not have to worry about your sugar intake. That’s because there are no sugars in this product. 

On top of being sugar-free dairy-free, and vegan-friendly, there are no artificial colors, flavors, oils, and trans-fat.

The mint chip ice cream is made with coconut milk; trust us, it tastes amazing! It costs approximately $4 to $5.

Ingredients:

• Organic coconut milk
• Locust bean gum
• Oatmilk
• Monk fruit extract
• Organic coconut water
• Guar gum
• Coconut oil
• Reb-A
• Erythritol
• Chocolate liquor
• Chicory root extract
• Pea protein
• Sunflower oil
• Cocoa
• Erythritol

What we liked:

• Sugar-free
• Gluten-free
• Non Dairy ice cream
• Mint chip

What we disliked:

• The fact that a single tub is never enough

5. So Delicious Vegan Vanilla Bean Ice Cream Bars

So Delicious makes such great ice cream that we had no choice but to include the brand twice on our list. Not only is it amazing, but it also helps you stick to a healthy diet. 

It’s a wonderful and tasty sweet treat that lets you enjoy eating ice cream while maintaining your health. Each box comes with four ice cream bars, and each bar has around 110 calories. So you will be able to control your calories without worrying.

The Vanilla Bean adds a lot of flavor to the ice cream. On top of that, the ice cream is a hundred percent vegan-friendly. It’s made of coconut and oat milk. 

Many stop eating ice cream because they want to control their sugar levels. But with this healthy ice cream, you will not have to worry about an increase in your blood sugar levels.

This product does contain a small amount of sugar — less than one gram per serving — but it’s almost negligible. 

The So Delicious Vegan Vanilla Bean Ice Cream costs about $8 to $9.

Ingredients:

• Organic Coconut Milk
• Locust Bean Gum
• Oatmilk
• Vanilla Bean Specks
• Organic Coconut Oil
• Monk Fruit Extract
• Chicory Root Extract
• Vanilla Extract
• Organic Erythritol
• Pea Protein
• Guar Gum
• Erythritol
• Reb-A
• Organic Sunflower Oil
• Natural Flavor
• Chocolate Liquor

What we liked:

• Vegan-friendly
• Dairy-free
• Gluten-free
• No added preservatives

What we disliked:

• A bit expensive for just four bars

How You Can Make Sugar-Free Vanilla Ice Cream at Home

Sugar-free ice cream is easy to make at home. Instead of sugar, generally, you use dextrose. It helps you make your ice cream sweet and softer than store-bought ice creams.

Vanilla Sugar-Free Ice Cream Recipe

Vanilla ice cream is an iconic and unbeatable flavor. Continue reading to find out how you can make it at home. 

Ingredients you need:

• 1 ¼ dextrose
• A pinch of salt
• 2 cups of milk
• 4 egg yolks (or egg substitute)
• One teaspoon of vanilla paste
• Thickened cream (300ml)

After you’ve gathered all these ingredients, follow the steps below:

• Step 1: Mix the dextrose and milk in a pan. 
• Step 2: Whisk the egg yolks and put them in the saucepan. 
• Step 3: Stir the mixture on medium heat until it starts to thicken up. It’s vital not to let it boil.
• Step 4: Pour in the vanilla paste.
• Step 5: After you are done, refrigerate the mixture for two hours. 
• Step 6: Stir your cream in a bowl and then pour it into your ice cream churner for around 20 mins or so. Read our review of the Hamilton Beach ice cream maker.
• Step 7: After you’re done, take it out and put it in a container. 
• Step 8: You can now refrigerate it for 24 hours until the ice cream becomes firm. 

Take it out and enjoy your sugar-free vanilla ice cream!

Plus, check out our recipe for a Failsafe Chocolate Sauce.

FAQs

Is it healthy to use artificial sweeteners?

The verdict on the use of artificial sweeteners and their effects is quite unsettled. Although some attest to having side effects after eating them, others consider it safe.

I have diabetes. Can I consume sugar-free ice cream?

Compared to your traditional ice creams, these are much safer for you to eat. It won’t impact your blood sugar levels as much. Still, it may be best to ask your doctor before introducing new foods to your diet.

What are the ice cream ingredients I should look out for?

It depends on your diet and the state of your body. If you’re suffering from heart disease or diabetes, the list can be long. In such cases, we advise avoiding ingredients containing added sugar or high sugar content. For those of you who are on a keto diet, forgo ingredients with high carb content.

Summary

In this article, we’ve shared with you our list of the best sugar free ice cream. You don’t have to fight your sweet tooth cravings anymore. If you’re diabetic or avoiding food items with added sugar in general, these make for great alternatives.

Besides being sugar-free, many of these ice creams are gluten-free, vegan-friendly, and contain no added preservatives.

But we also advise you don’t binge on these treats. Like all things, eat them in moderation. Remember to share this news with your friends as well. Tell us about your favorite ice cream by commenting down below. Also, if you like gelatos, make sure you check out our review of the Best Gelato Maker.